News re Muir Valley

[Andrew]

It would be nice if the Access Fund or some other entity could spread donations to all the areas in the red.

Say I give $100, $25 goes to Muir, $25 goes to RRGCC, $25 goes to badbolts.com and $25 goes to fighting to get roadside open.

Each time you climb?

[Steve_RRG]

I know money doesn't grow on trees, but you can't do any other activity for $10 per day per person. If you can't afford that, drive to the nearest national park that allows climbing and see how much that costs. Gee whiz, just pay the $10 and be darn glad to have such a wonderful place to climb so close to home.

[Ken84il]

Steve is right on the money. How much do we spend on gear, tents, sleeping bags, patagonia down sweaters and blah blah blah.. if you can't afford 10 bucks a day or 20 even y did you get into such an expensive hobby. Don't get me wrong, i have climbed at muir without a donation on occasion.. but i am happy to help with parking, fundraising, trail day, etc to make up for those weekends where money is tight. So many ppl simply, drive in from where ever, park, climb, then leave.. only to return the following day to do the same.. Drop a days beer money in the box and have a couple glasses of water-

[ynp1]

No, you did not Ken! I will never go with out my beer! You are just being unreasonable...

Truthfully though, $100,000 annual cost is crazy. It doesn't sound like it was designed to be very sustainable, with out a lot of funding. Maybe the FOMV will figure out how to get that cost down. Good Luck to all!

[Ken84il]

[Cromper]

Truthfully though, $100,000 annual cost is crazy. It doesn't sound like it was designed to be very sustainable, with out a lot of funding. Maybe the FOMV will figure out how to get that cost down. Good Luck to all!

True dat.

[Andrew]

Steve is right on the money. How much do we spend on gear, tents, sleeping bags, patagonia down sweaters and blah blah blah.. if you can't afford 10 bucks a day or 20 even y did you get into such an expensive hobby. Don't get me wrong, i have climbed at muir without a donation on occasion.. but i am happy to help with parking, fundraising, trail day, etc to make up for those weekends where money is tight. So many ppl simply, drive in from where ever, park, climb, then leave.. only to return the following day to do the same.. Drop a days beer money in the box and have a couple glasses of water-

I completely agree, but years of data provided by the webers have proved that the community isn't willing to pony up on a consistent basis.

[Savage]

No, you did not Ken! I will never go with out my beer! You are just being unreasonable...

Truthfully though, $100,000 annual cost is crazy. It doesn't sound like it was designed to be very sustainable, with out a lot of funding. Maybe the FOMV will figure out how to get that cost down. Good Luck to all!

I think it is important to reiterate that while the $200k goes toward 2014 and 2015 operational costs, it is not exclusively for that. Some money is going toward the land transfer, as well as set up a stewardship fund. So presumeably, they are setting up a fund to help pay for stuff in the future. I dont have the actually estimated yearly operation costs, but it is not $100k/yr.

[climb2core]

Expenses HAVE historically averaged at $100k per yer.

http://friendsofmuirvalley.dreamhosters.com/financials/

The question becomes if FoMV will be able to reduce those in the future.

[Savage]

Expenses HAVE historically averaged at $100k per yer.

http://friendsofmuirvalley.dreamhosters.com/financials/

The question becomes if FoMV will be able to reduce those in the future.

you are right on what they have spent, i didnt realize that. However, when you look at it, all the big ticket stuff is related to infrastructure, materials, and labor. I dont see that continuing. The vault toilets are a prime expample of that. Lots of material and labor went into that and will not be a recurring cost, at least not at that level. Think of all the new big bridges that went in, like to solarium. That isnt going to need to be rebuilt every year. It is going to last.

But your point is well received. THe operational costs need to be cut down, or they need to charge people to climb there.

[Willy]

[/quote] or they need to charge people to climb there.[/quote]
+1

Paying for parking has been discussed. What are the logistical issues with this? Even if someone had to be employed to collect the funds on busy weekends it would still be very worthwhile IMO.

[Savage]

thats a good idea. Perhaps offer a day pass, weekend pass, or year pass. Maybe make it a tax deductible thing too, to encourage people to just get the year pass or whatever.

[Steve_RRG]

Donations to FOMV are now tax deductible. If they can figure out how to "force" daily donations for parking, you should still be able to write it off as a donation. Many of the "Visitors Centers" I have been in have a welcome counter when you first come in with big signs "suggesting" a donation of $5 or $10 per person.

[Liz_Weber]

I initially said I would try to answer questions about Rick's and my plans to make a gift of Muir Valley to FOMV on the MV Facebook page. I have gotten so many that it has been cumbersome to keep up on FB. Instead I've tried to answer the questions I've received on the MV web page: http://www.muirvalley.com/answers.html

I'm sorry that I haven't had time to respond to all of the personal messages, but thank you so much. If you send questions to [email protected] I'll try to add answers to the above site.

Liz

[mjkusn01]

I initially said I would try to answer questions about Rick's and my plans to make a gift of Muir Valley to FOMV on the MV Facebook page. I have gotten so many that it has been cumbersome to keep up on FB. Instead I've tried to answer the questions I've received on the MV web page: http://www.muirvalley.com/answers.html

I'm sorry that I haven't had time to respond to all of the personal messages, but thank you so much. If you send questions to [email protected] I'll try to add answers to the above site.

Liz

Thanks for posting. Interesting (audacious) questions some people ask...